SC decision allowing Sen Poe to run (over turning Comelec decision her) throws Presidential wanna bees in disarray

It is more fun criticizing

                             Sen Poe and Justice Tony Carpio;- strongly against Poes candidacy

                                   Carpio - Sen Poe is a naturlized Filipino citizen
                              There are no parents in her birth certificate and yet represented in
                              her documents for dual citizenship that she is born to Fernando
                              Poe and Susan Roces. (I am convinced here of Justice Carpios stand)


Rizal Philippines
March 9, 2019

In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court ruled 9-6 in favor of Sen Grace Poe allowing her to run. Only the result of the voting was announced by SC spokesman and not the basis for voting. The two issues are the 10 years residency and Sen Poe being a natural born citizen.  (The grapevine says she was born in US)  But some say that she is likely to have US support.  Duterte does not have that support for antagonizing US, for having leanings towards the left and its erstwhile leader Jo Ma Sison.  (US embassy denied having an appt. set for Duterte)

The detractors of the good Senator says though that the legal arguments  by SC allowing her to run  are weak.  Lawyer Estrella Elamparo said she is shocked at the ruling.   Many commented that the decision runs smack vs the constitution.

From GMA news - Sen Grace Poes qualification may still be questioned

The Presidenatiables hoping for swing votes in case Sen Poe was disqualified have to work very hard.  Sen Grace Poe is  ahead of the polls. VP Binay or Sec. Roxas could have benefitted from the Poe disqualification.

We may yet have a another lady President.

Sen Myriam and Sec Roxas are not in the running.  Duterte, Binay, and Poe are in the peloton.

Did Sen Grace Poe reacquire her natural born status under RA 9225? Did she really use her US passport 7x?

It is more fun criticizing

Rizal Philippines
December 15, 2015

Justice Carpio has argued that she is not a a natural born Filipino but naturalized and thus can not run as President under the 1986 constitution

There are two issues against her:  that of her residency and being a natural born citizen.

The biggest issue against her, according to one in the know I talked this morning is about her citizenship;
1.  At the time she "reacquired" her Filipino citizenship she used her US passport 7x.  If indeed she was all ready a Filipino citizen, by deed she would have used her Philippine passport.

2.  Our Philippine constitution:  the 1935 and the 1986 does not guarantee that you maintain your Filipino status once you acquire another citizenship as in the Spanish constitution.  Once the citizenship is renounced, as in the case of Sen Grace Poe, the only way to reacquire this is by naturalization, thus her status of naturalized citizen

But Section 3 of RA 9225 (AN ACT MAKING THE CITIZENSHIP OF PHILIPPINE CITIZENS WHO ACQUIRE FOREIGN CITIZENSHIP PERMANENT) says that after taking an oath, gives her back her status of natural born citizen, after having been a citizen of foreign country.  Did she take this oath

                                                 IRR of RA 9225

Valenzuela City Mayor Win  Gatchalian said she did reacquire her Filipino citizenship under this law.?

Other references:

Q and A on Poe citizenship at FB

Family Law expert says Sen Grace Poe is natural born (as all foundlings found in the Philippines should be)